Daily Newsletter

04 December 2023

Daily Newsletter

04 December 2023

Lords: MoD need ‘complete reset’ for AI and autonomous weapons

A report from the House of Lords on AI enabled Autonomous Weapon Systems indicates that MoD procurement will need to keep pace with innovation.

Andrew Salerno-Garthwaite December 01 2023

Army Technology interviewed Lord Robert Lisvane, Chair of the House of Lords Inquiry into AI enabled Autonomous Weapon Systems (AWS) that has published, 1 December, a report recommending the UK government seeks public support in implementing wider use of AWS in defence.

The report, 'Proceed with Caution: Artificial Intelligence in Weapon Systems', also suggested that meaningful human oversight be embedded at every stage of development and deployment, and that Artificial intelligence should be prohibited in nuclear command, control and communications.

“Although AI enabled intelligence gathering may feed into political and military decisions made, particularly in a period of heightened tension, we were very clear that the escalatory risks of consigning decisions to artificial intelligence in the nuclear sphere was not acceptable.”

MoD procurement needs a 'complete reset' for AI enabled AWS

Lord Lisvane stated the Committee’s evidence indicates procurement for AI enabled AWS needs a 'complete reset' in order to match the constantly updating pairing of capability and requirement. 

The report is explicit that the Ministry of Defence needs to have capacity, either in house or on contract, to assess bid 'on tap', and to impose meaningful conditions during through-life support of the systems. The upshot defence economy efficiencies from this pattern of development is,  Lord Lisvane notes, that with the rate of adaptation being so much more increased, “gold plating may actually not be very easy to do”, implying prestige assets may be an alien concept to the sector. 

“If you're looking at AI enabled AWS, it's such a long way from procuring a fast jet, or a new frigate. And whereas the timeline, from operational requirement to tendering contract, trials, deployment could be as long as thirty years. We're now talking in terms of a period of procurement, possibly going really quite rapidly, to potential deployment which could be measured in months.”

Potential for reduction in collateral damage

Witnesses at the inquiry offered evidence that AWS, with appropriate controls, may reduce casualties normally defined as collateral damage, offering commanders fires that can be more selective and precise, but as Lord Lisvane notes, this should also be taken in balance. “If you're dealing with an AWS and not with, let us say, a human piloted aircraft, an attack might be pressed home with more fervour and determination in the AWS mode, than it would [with] pilots who are worrying about being shot down.”

Central to the findings of the report, titled 'Proceed with Caution: Artificial Intelligence in Weapon Systems',  is the recommendation to the government to fully define AI enabled Autonomous Weapon Systems, so that legislators a use this definition to enact regulation.

"If circumstances meant that something wholly unforeseen, was developed, then you'd need also, I think, to have agreement on how a definition should be amended.”

Lord Robert Lisvane

The Committee offered two levels of definition. ‘Fully’ autonomous weapon systems are systems that, once activated, can identify, select, and engage targets with lethal force without further intervention by an operator, while ‘Partially’ autonomous weapon systems are defined  as, systems featuring varying degrees of decision-making autonomy in critical functions such as identification, classification, interception and engagement. 

“We're pretty confident that our definition is a robust one, and resilient, at least against foreseeable change,” said Lord Lisvane, crediting the practical worth to the avoidance of technical detail. "We've simply said, 'If the system exhibits these behaviours, it will fall into the definition of either fully or partially autonomous.' He outlines the benefit for a stable definition as laying the foundation for international agreement on AI enabled AWS, but adds that revision is also consideration. "If circumstances meant that something wholly unforeseen, was developed, then you'd need also, I think, to have agreement on how a definition should be amended.”

Emerging threats are reviving interest in advanced materials (AdMs)

Investment in AdMs has remained relatively constant due to its ubiquity in the defense sector, however, the emergence of new applications for AdMs and new threats such as hypersonic weapons are driving a global reevaluation of the importance of AdMs to military modernization efforts.

Analyzing the role of IoT in defense

The applications of IoT in defense are wide-ranging and include health monitoring, AR remote training, gaining situational awareness using drones, vehicle management, target recognition, and many more. For instance, smart sensors can be used on military equipment to give data on their health and whether maintenance is needed. This helps reduce operating costs and downtime for military equipment.

Newsletters by sectors

close

Sign up to the newsletter: In Brief

Visit our Privacy Policy for more information about our services, how we may use, process and share your personal data, including information of your rights in respect of your personal data and how you can unsubscribe from future marketing communications. Our services are intended for corporate subscribers and you warrant that the email address submitted is your corporate email address.

Thank you for subscribing

View all newsletters from across the GlobalData Media network.

close